Does Art Respect Animals?

il_570xN_272505941

The painting above is of a cow, but does it respect the cow? Artist, Tina Kolberg, has some fascinating insights on this. Here’s her thoughts:

Does Art Respect Animals?

“I saw a collage artwork once that struck me. The artist had made a large portrait of a cow out of clippings about cows. For example, one snippet read “With a / And a / Here a / There a / Everywhere a.” The last words of each line were cut off, but it was obviously “Old McDonald.”

The collage was a cow made up of things we think about cows. Which is not really a cow, it’s just our thoughts. I’m not sure if the artist was aware of this wonderful ironic disconnect, this reduction to nursery songs, or if he really thought he was cleverly reinforcing the cow image with true cow information.

When I think about most realistic paintings that have animals in them, it seems as though the artist has brought their assumptions to the work. Perhaps cows in a field are pretty and give one a sense of pastoral peace and comfort. And cows mean plenty to eat. Chickens are so ridiculous, scratching around. Usually they’re painted with warm, honey tones (golds and reds), and I think their purpose is to make us feel comfortable.

Wildlife, on the other hand, is usually painted in cooler tones (blues). Think of duck hunting art, such as the painting below with the cold blues and browns of ducks in a pond.

images

“Totally Committed” – Waterfowl Hunting by Peter Corbin

What is the artist telling us with this choice? Maybe he’s saying, “enjoy the plumage but don’t get attached – it’s a cold world and we need to kill or die.”

Now compare the hunters art with my Cayuga Mallard below.

2010-06-watercolor-cayuga-mallard

“Cayuga Mallard” by Tina Kolberg

Admittedly, I painted mine in cool colors, too, but which painting do you think someone who kills ducks would prefer?

The Western Cow Painting below is an example of farm animal art.

il_570xN_272505941

Western Cow Painting & Blue Sky Art Print from Jemma’s Gems Original Painting

The artist probably believes she loves cows, just as the hunter artist believes he respects ducks, but they are bringing their own needs to the art. Notice that this cow is tagged, full-uddered, and rather stupid-looking. Its body is shown, but no eyes.

In contrast, below is a pastel cow I painted.

2012-07-17-pastel-cow-1

Maybe the cow’s body is more convenient for some artists than its thoughts or feelings. Or maybe some artists are deliberately showing exactly what I’ve been saying: we reduce animals to objects because we have to in order to use them.

Perhaps I’m too harsh, reading too much into it and projecting my views and values onto others’ artwork without justification. Certainly there are exceptions, like wild bird art (e.g. songbirds), which is often painted with dignity and affection. Compare wild bird art with duck hunting art and decide for yourself.

You may find it enlightening to Google “Cow Art” and see whether you can glean how the artists’ feel about their animal subjects. Do you notice a difference between many of these and my cow painting above? How does this compare with art about humans, portraits vs. nudes?

Not everything follows this pattern (keep in mind that Audubon Art, of any animal, is about science), but is there a trend?  I’m not claiming that any of these paintings are “bad art.” I think the purpose of art is to show a particular viewpoint.

Still, how much do we really see of an animal, as she really is?  How much of it is stories, songs and ideas rather than reality? Do cows need to give milk? Do cows feel useful when they see happy children eating ice cream? Do cows not really care about their babies? Do we need to eat ducks? Are we really doing wildlife a favor when we hunt?

We usually answer these questions in ways that meet our own needs instead of looking clearly and determining reality as best we can. Once I said no to eating animal products, I could answer questions like these in a less self-serving way, and I believe more honestly.” – Tina Kolberg

I loved this part of Tina’s write-up, but there’s still more! Check in tomorrow for part 3.

The “Totally Committed” Waterfowl Hunting painting is by Peter Corbin and can be found on Wildlife Experience.

About celestedimilla

Hey there. I’m Celeste, California girl, writer, psychotherapist and burgeoning plant-based foodie.
Aside | This entry was posted in Animal Welfare, Daily Life and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Does Art Respect Animals?

  1. Whoa. Really fascinating perspective on this! I will never look at animal/wildlife artwork in the same way! Thank you for sharing this.

  2. sophiazerg says:

    Celeste, I have really been enjoying these art & animal posts, I read them back to back today. As always, awe-inspiring. You rock, and I nominated you for the Shine On Award! Feel free to participate!
    Check it out here: http://silkandspiceblog.wordpress.com/2013/07/24/shine-on-my-first-much-appreciated-award/
    Sophia 🙂

    • So glad you liked Tina’s ‘animal art’ mini series Sophia. I thought she had a lot of fascinating stuff to share and I love her art so much! And thank you so very much for nominating me for the Shine On Award. It quite an honor – I’m so touched!! Celeste 🙂

      • sophiazerg says:

        It was really interesting to see in which manner the animals were painted, and the respect behind it. Really cool.
        You are most welcome for the nomination!
        Sophia 🙂

  3. Sophie33 says:

    Waw, indeed! These are beautiful paintings! thanks! 🙂 x

  4. Pingback: Does Art Respect Animals? « The Expanding Circle

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s